Exclusive INDYCAR Nation News

Momentum shifts with Franchitti’s error

Kyle Lavigne
| Sep 18, 2011

The ebb and flow of the 2011 title fight could rival that of any other year. Several times this year, either Will Power or Dario Franchitti appeared to have the measure of his rival only to lose it during the next race.

Sunday’s Indy Japan The Final was yet another cog in that swing swinging pendulum. As Will Power had a quietly efficient run to second, Dario Franchitti had to dig out of a hole he threw himself into with one poorly timed move.

On a lap 25 restart, Franchitti, then running fifth, took a look inside of Ryan Briscoe, who was already on the inside line entering turn one with Charlie Kimball next to him. Franchitti knew he’d made a mistake immediately and tried to back out of it, but the hole closed before he could get out of the way. He pitched Briscoe into a spin that also collected Graham Rahal (Briscoe made contact with Rahal after he was turned) and forced Kimball into the gravel trap.

Franchitti didn’t mince his words and accepted full responsibility. “The incident was totally my mistake, totally my mistake,” said the disappointed Scotsman. “I did a lot hard work to get from ninth to fifth, and I'd been saving fuel the whole first stint. I made risky move on the restart. I thought there was a gap and Ryan (Briscoe) was going wide on the entry and that was that. I apologized to Graham and I apologized to Chip. Briscoe and Charlie (Kimball) I will apologize to when I see him. I own up to the mistake and Chip is right to be critical. It was a stupid move, and I shouldn't have done it."

In terms of the championship, he was philosophical about the effects Sunday’s run could have. “If you win or if you lose, you always look at the championship as a whole. Today, Loudon, Texas, Indy and on and on. You always look at these things, but Will (Power) can do the same with his races. That was a mistake today. Shouldn't have made it.” Of course, it could have been much worse. Franchitti rallied to finish eighth, far better than most would have predicted after the contact.

With that said, Power seemed to be on cruise control behind Dixon, stalking him the entire way. He couldn’t grab the win, but the result is exactly what he and Verizon Team Penske wanted. “I just need to keep finishing in front of the 10 car the rest of the way and we'll be fine,” said Power. “We'll keep chipping away like we have been.”

In finishing second, Power also claimed the Mario Andretti Trophy for the Road Course Championship, the second year in a row he’ll hold the crown as the series’ best road and street racer. “It's an honor to win the Mario Andretti Road Course award again - I have such respect for Mario and all he's accomplished,” he said of the accomplishment. “Now, we need to keep going and finish the season strong on the ovals.

Race Control’s Inconsistency Wearing on Drivers

The other entity that will have the lion’s share of the criticism is Race Control. The manner in which penalties were assigned by Brian Barnhart, Tony Cotman, and Al Unser Jr., who all call the race together, is at the forefront of the controversy.

Franchitti was penalized for his role in that lap 25 restart, but it was a different penalty than they had been giving. Since Edmonton, penalties for avoidable contact have come in the form of drive-throughs. However, in this case, Franchitti was simply moved to the back of field, where he already was running after he pitted for a new front wing. That decision drew the ire of Wally Dallenbach and Robin Miller during VERSUS’ broadcast.

However, the ruling that drew headlines, albeit for the reaction it got, was Helio Castroneves’ penalty for passing under a local caution. With two laps remaining, Hideki Mutoh spun and stalled in turn three. No full-course caution was flown, but a local yellow was issued, meaning that drivers were not allowed to overtake in that corner. Castroneves, battling with J.R. Hildebrand for seventh, passed him in that corner on the final lap and failed to give it up. A penalty beckoned. Castroneves was moved down the finishing order to 22nd.

The Penske driver took to twitter after the race and fired his anger in the direction of race officials. Even though Castroneves deserved a penalty, his words were very condemning of the team in Race Control on the way Franchitti was “penalized” and the lack of one for Sebastien Bourdais, who spun Ryan Hunter-Reay late in the going in turn three as well. 

The officials have come under fire numerous times this year, with the criticism getting louder. It has been at an all-time high since Loudon, with more of the drivers now publicly lashing out.


  1. 1 Dissertation writing services 24 Jan
    The article seems to befit the title given to it. We are here for your dissertation writing needs.
  2. 2 How to write a research paper 18 Jan
    A research is supposed to be the true representation of the efforts and dedication put into writing and preparing something.
  3. 3 How to write a research proposal 17 Jan
    Before a research takes place, a proposal has to be written stating the hows and whys of the research.
  4. 4 What is a research proposal 16 Jan
    There is no comparison between a well researched article and an article that hasn't been well-researched.
  5. 5 How to write a dissertation 16 Jan
    Quite a thoughtfully written piece here.
  6. 6 How to become a successful freelance writer 15 Jan
    As the saying goes, only hard work leads to success.
  7. 7 Common mistakes with critical essays 14 Jan
    It was critical indeed.
  8. 8 Essay Writing Service 09 Jan
  9. 9 Paper Writing Service 09 Jan


  10. 10 hilary 20 Dec
  11. 11 Molly 05 Nov
    This is exaclty what I was looking for. Thanks for writing!
  12. 12 splqejub 25 Oct
    CJ4Q1q , [url=http://uggdgncwqamb.com/]uggdgncwqamb[/url], [link=http://oufswaapjdoi.com/]oufswaapjdoi[/link], http://qptiprfendoc.com/
  13. 13 Bobcat 24 Oct
    Do you have more great atricles like this one?
  14. 14 miken 02 Oct

    Seems I was right about Al. Drag racing a Suburbon while under the influince. No wonder he sees things different when he makes the judgement calls about on track incidents! Way to go Indycar!


  15. 15 Julie 19 Sep

    On the Race Control’s Inconsistency Wearing on Drivers section:

    The fact is that Dario was penalized for avoidable contact and that penalty was consistent with the penalties handed out for similar incidents. An article on Pop-off Valve explains the avoidable contact penalty that he got from a driver: If a driver is charged with avoidable contact that does not result in a DNF, then the penalty is being sent to the back of the field. If the avoidable contact results in a DNF, then the penalty is a green-flag drive through. Since the incident did not result in a DNF, the correct penalty was given. To be honest, I am not sure how sure how all the incidents in Edmonton line up with the above explanantion...I no longer have the race on my DVR. I think a lot of people were more upset that Dario's skill as a driver made it possible for him to recover fairly well from the penalty leading people to believe he was not truely "punished" for the incident. 

    A lot of people point to Ryan Briscoe's penalty in Baltimore as a sign of the inconsistencies because he served a drive through for contact with RHR and the 15+ car pile-up. Briscoe was originally told to go to the back of the field but because he was either unwilling or unable to safely move to the back of the field, he was told to serve a drive-through penalty to get himself to the back of the field.

    I will agree that there are inconsistencies in the officiating but I do not think it is as bad as people are making out. I think it is the "where there's smoke, there's fire" theory....becuase there have been bad calls, all most calls are bad.

    I am not sure how Helio could comment on the penalty for Franchitti or lack of penalty for Bourdais when he was not involved in the incidents. The way I see it, the only ones that can complain are Briscoe, Rahal, Kimble and Hunter-Reay.  

  16. 16 mike n 19 Sep
    Is Indycar for #$%^@#! for real? No penalty for Dario Judds DUMB-ASS move? Castroneves is moved to 22nd, so as to give Dario Judd 2 more points. Barnhart, Cotman, Unser,you guys SUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Your making a total JOKE of the series!!!! Little Al must still be hitting the sauce, Barnhart and Cotman must be joining him and Ganassi must be picking up the bar tab!

You are not allowed to post comments.